Earnest Money When an Ohio Deal Falls Apart
The deal died and the deposit is still sitting somewhere. Most articles tell you the seller usually keeps it. Ohio’s statute says something narrower and more useful: here are the only five ways that money legally moves, and why a broker who simply pays you out is doing it wrong.
A single sealed moving box with a set of house keys on top, alone on bare floorboards in an empty room
Ohio law does not decide who deserves the deposit — your contract does. What the statute controls is how a broker holding it may release it, and there are exactly five ways. "The seller says the buyer defaulted" is not one of them. In practice a stuck deposit moves when both sides sign, or when a court orders it.
When a sale collapses, the deposit turns into the argument. The buyer says their financing contingency saved them. You say they got cold feet after you took the house off the market for six weeks. Both of you ring the brokerage, and the brokerage does nothing.
That is not the brokerage being unhelpful. It is the brokerage following a statute that most articles about this subject never mention.
Holding it and deserving it are different questions
This is the distinction that makes everything else make sense, and nearly every page you will read blurs it.
Who is entitled to the money is a contract question. It turns on what your purchase agreement says, which contingencies it contained, whether the buyer met their deadlines, and what remedies the agreement gives you. That is between you and the buyer, and if you cannot agree, it is between you, the buyer and a judge.
Who may release the money is a licensing question, and Ohio answers it precisely. Where earnest money sits in a real estate broker’s trust or special account, the broker must maintain it there in accordance with the terms of the purchase agreement until one of five specific things happens.
The five exits, and nothing else
- The sale closes — the broker disburses to the closing or escrow agent, or otherwise as the purchase agreement directs.
- Both parties sign separate written instructions specifying how the broker is to disburse it, and the broker acts on those instructions.
- A court decides — the broker receives a copy of a final court order specifying who the money goes to, and acts on it.
- A record owner cancels under Ohio’s wholesaler disclosure law, and the broker disburses to that owner.
- It becomes unclaimed funds under Ohio’s unclaimed funds law and is reported and remitted in full to the director of commerce.
Read that list again for what is missing. There is no exit for "the seller is obviously right". There is no exit for "the buyer stopped answering the phone". There is no exit for the broker forming a view about who breached. A broker who pays out on one party’s say-so is not being decisive — failing to comply with this section is its own ground for disciplinary sanctions against the licensee.
Deal fell through and not sure where you stand?
Tell us what your contract says and what happened. We will give you our honest read on where the deposit sits — and if the answer is that you need a lawyer rather than a buyer, we will say so.
The two-year rule that is not automatic
You will read that Ohio lets a broker return a disputed deposit to the buyer after two years. That is close, but the part that gets dropped matters enormously: it applies only if your purchase agreement contains a specific provision allowing it.
The statute says a purchase agreement may provide that, on a dispute, the broker will return the money to the purchaser without notice unless, within two years of the deposit, the broker receives either written instructions signed by both parties or written notice that a court action has been filed. The deadline rule then applies only "if the purchase agreement contains the provision".
So there are two quite different worlds depending on a clause you may never have read. And note which way the clause cuts: where it exists, the default outcome of a long stalemate is that the buyer gets the money back.
What a long-running dispute looks like, with and without the clause
| Agreement has the division (B) clause | Agreement does not | |
|---|---|---|
| If nobody acts | Broker returns the deposit to the purchaser by the statutory deadline. | Nothing happens. The money stays in the trust account. |
| What stops that | Written instructions signed by both parties, or written notice that a court action has been filed. | Not applicable — there is no clock to stop. |
| The deadline | Not later than the first day of September following the two-year anniversary of the deposit. | None. |
| Who it favours | The buyer, if the seller does nothing. | Neither — it favours inertia. |
Summarised from ORC 4735.24(B) and (C)(1). Whether your agreement contains the clause is a question about your paperwork, not about Ohio law — read it, ideally before you sign rather than after a deal collapses.
The deadline is worth working through slowly, because it is not the round number people repeat. It is not "two years from the deposit". It is the first day of September following the two-year anniversary. A deposit made in October 2026 reaches its two-year anniversary in October 2028, and the return falls due by 1 September 2029 — nearly three years after the deal died.
If the buyer disappears
One more branch, and it surprises sellers. If the broker cannot locate the purchaser when the disbursement is due, the money does not fall to you by default. The broker gives the notice Ohio’s unclaimed funds law requires, reports it as unclaimed funds to the director of commerce, and remits all of it to the state.
We are not going to describe how the state’s unclaimed funds process works from there, because we have not read those sections. The statute names them; that is as far as we will go.
Want the contract read before you sign the next one?
If your house is going back on the market, we are happy to look at the next offer with you — including offers from other buyers. Knowing what the deposit clause says beforehand is worth more than arguing about it afterwards.
Where none of this applies
This section is specifically about money sitting in a real estate broker’s trust or special account. That is the ordinary situation in a listed sale.
When a title company or escrow agent holds the deposit instead — which is common in a direct sale, including ours — different arrangements govern what releases it. We are not going to summarise rules we have not read this week. The useful move is the same either way: ask whoever is holding your deposit what it takes to release it, and get that answer in writing before you need it.
Your options after a collapsed sale
Keep the house
A failed sale is information, not an instruction. If the reason for selling has eased, stopping is a real option and costs nothing further.
Repair what killed the deal
If an inspection ended it, you now know what the next buyer will find. Fixing it is often cheaper than discounting for it twice.
Rent it instead
Worth weighing if the house is already empty and carrying costs are the pressure. It does not resolve the deposit question, which continues on its own track.
Relist it
Common, and often right. Commissions in our area run 5.5% to 6%, and this time you can ask what the agreement says about earnest money before you sign it.
Sell it yourself
You will be drafting or reviewing the deposit terms yourself, so read this article again before you do. A deposit held by nobody in particular is the worst arrangement of all.
Sell direct for cash
Fewer contingencies means fewer of the things that collapse deals, and we can close as fast as seven days where circumstances allow, though a typical close runs around 21 days. That is a different risk profile, not automatically a better price — compare the net.
Plenty of pages will tell you what earnest money "typically" is, as a dollar figure or a percentage of the price. We have no source for that in Ohio that we can read and check, so we are not quoting one. What matters for your deal is the number written on your own contract, and whether the clause governing it works the way you assumed.
This describes Ohio statutes as we read them and is not legal advice. Who is entitled to a disputed deposit depends on your contract and your facts, which we cannot see. If real money is stuck, an hour with an Ohio real estate attorney is usually cheaper than the argument.
If you would rather just talk it through
Call or text and tell us what happened. We will tell you what we think your options are, including the ones that do not involve selling to us at all. No cost and nothing to sign.
Frequently asked questions
No. Whether you are entitled to it depends on your purchase contract and its contingencies, not on any statute. What Ohio law controls is how the money is handled: where a broker holds it, there are only five things that let the broker release it, and a seller asserting the buyer defaulted is not one of them.
The transaction closes and the broker disburses to the closing or escrow agent or as the contract directs; both parties sign separate written instructions saying how to disburse it; the broker receives a copy of a final court order; the record owner cancels under Ohio’s wholesaler disclosure law; or it becomes unclaimed funds and is remitted to the director of commerce.
Only if your purchase agreement contains a specific clause allowing it. The statute says a purchase agreement "may provide" for that, and the deadline rule applies only where the agreement contains that provision. Without the clause, there is no two-year reset — the stalemate simply continues until both sides sign or a court decides.
Not on the anniversary itself. Where the clause applies, the broker must return the money to the purchaser no later than the first day of September following the two-year anniversary of the deposit. Depending on when the deposit went in, that can be closer to three years than two.
If the broker cannot locate the purchaser when disbursement is due, the broker gives the notice Ohio’s unclaimed funds law requires, reports the money as unclaimed funds to the director of commerce, and remits all of it. It does not default to the seller.
You can ask, and a conscientious broker will say no. Failing to comply with this section is its own ground for disciplinary sanctions against the licensee, so a broker who pays out on one party’s say-so is risking their licence, not doing you a favour.
Usually the cheapest way: both sides sign a release saying how to split it. Otherwise it takes a court order. Those are the two routes in the statute that resolve a genuine disagreement, and the first one is almost always faster and cheaper than the second.
This section is about money in a real estate broker’s trust or special account. When a title company or escrow agent holds it, different arrangements govern, and we are not going to describe rules we have not read. Ask the company holding your deposit what releases it, and get the answer before you need it.
Find out what we would pay
Free, no obligation, and no pressure. If our number does not work for you, that is a perfectly fine answer.
Keep reading
Investor vs. Realtor
What an Ohio Listing Agreement Must Legally Contain
Ohio requires your agreement to say, conspicuously, that commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. Most sellers never notice the sentence.
The Cash Offer Process
Are "We Buy Houses" Companies Legit? 10 Things to Check Before You Sign
Most are real businesses, some are not, and Ohio gives you specific ways to tell. Ten checks you can run in an afternoon — including on us.
The Cash Offer Process
How the Cash Offer Process Works — Step by Step
Every step from your first call to money in your account, including who does what, what a title company actually does, and where the process can go wrong.